Skip to main content
logo

2022 Annual Conference

May 19–21, 2022

Sheraton Sand Key, Clearwater Beach, FL, US

Proposal authors can use this tool to see where they have been placed in the program agenda for an Oral or Poster Session.

Scroll down to search by the Submitter or Author Name, by Date/Time, or by Keywords.

Confirm your place in the schedule by going to the ACCI Presenter Confirm Google Sheet and marking your session with the name and email address of the author who will be attending and presenting. Each presentation must have a separate paid registraint. Contact the ACCI Office immedicately by email at admin@consumerinterests.org to report a conflict or if you have questions. Please be sure to reference the session title(s), date(s), and time(s) if you contact us.

G1b Exploring Measurement Issues in Assessing K-12 Financial Education

Saturday, May 21, 2022 at 10:30 AM–12:00 PM EDT
Room 1
Key Words

financial education, young adults, recall bias, NFCS, achievement gap

Short Description

Assessments of high school financial education are largely based on self-reported measures, resulting in potentially biased findings. Yet, recent implementation studies reveal that many schools unsuccessfully offer personal finance courses. Hence, I compare measures of "mandated" with measures of "recalled" in testing the role of recall in high school financial education effects. I employ pooled data on financial education receipt and financial behaviors from the National Financial Capability Study and longitudinal data on K-12 educational environments from the U.S. Department of Education and Urban Institute's Education Data Portal. I use variation in timing and presence of state-required personal finance coursework in high schools to estimate propensities for young adults from mandated states to self-report receipt; to assess how recall enhances effects on behaviors; and to discern who is more likely to have a discrepancy. I preliminary find that while mandates are positively associated with self-reported receipt and self-reported receipt display higher effects from mandates, women and urban residents are more likely to have a discrepancy between the two data sources. This warrants further investigation in ensuring that these policies are not further exaceberating gaps among certain subgroups.

Submitter

Melody Harvey, University of Wisconsin-Madison

Authors

Melody Harvey, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Loading…