Skip to main content
logo

2019 Conference

May 21–23, 2019

Westin Arlington Gateway, Arlington, VA, USA

Proposal authors can use this tool to see where they have been placed in the agenda for a Symposium, an Oral Session, or a Featured Research Poster Session.

Scroll down to search by Author Name (Note: if the submitting author did not add all authors to the ProposalSpace form, only First & Corresponding Author will be searchable), by Date/Time, or by Keywords.

Confirm your place in the schedule by going to the ACCI Presenter Confirm Google Sheet and marking your session YES. Contact the ACCI Office to report a conflict. Call (727) 940-2658 x 2002 if you have questions. Please be sure to reference the session title(s), date(s) and time(s) if you contact us.


A1b Consumer Perceptions of Financial Occupational Titles and Implications for Advisory Title Regulation

Tuesday, May 21, 2019 at 5:15 PM–6:45 PM EDT
F. Scott Fitzgerald A
Key Words

Consumer perceptions, Financial advisory titles, Title regulation, FINRA, SEC, Brokers, Consumer protection

Short Description

Many professionals in the financial services industry refer to themselves as financial advisors despite tremendous variation in business practices, compensation methods, and duties to act in the best interest of one's client. These variations are believed to result in consumer confusion, however, there is little empirical evidence to inform how consumers actually perceive the use of such titles. This study examines consumer perceptions via a survey of U.S. consumers conducted using Amazon's Mechanical Turk (n = 654). Principal components analysis of semantic differential ratings of professional characteristics indicates two dimensions of particular importance to consumers which appear to coincide with two primary duties of a fiduciary: (1) loyalty (high factor loadings on dimensions of honesty, care, other serving, trustworthiness, helpfulness, and depth) and (2) competence (high factor loadings on dimensions of intelligence, work ethic, and success). Further, results from k-means cluster analysis indicate that consumers perceive common industry titles as fundamentally different from one another in a manner that is consistent with the differentiation of advice professions (e.g., doctor, lawyer, financial advisor, financial consultant) from sales professions (e.g., car salesperson, investment salesperson, stockbroker, life insurance agent). Consumer protection implications of these findings for FINRA and SEC policy proposals are discussed.

First & Corresponding Author

Derek Tharp, University of Southern Maine
Authors in the order to be printed

Derek Tharp

Additional Authors

Loading…